Abmelde-Agent: Fälle, Zeitlauf und Agent-Dienst (Vikunja 97) (#3)

This commit was merged in pull request #3.
This commit is contained in:
Rsclub2_2 committed 2026-11-16 07:41:08 +01:00
1 parent a9ba08bfe0
commit e0e8cad4de
36 files changed
+4385 -8

No files matched your search

+380
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,380 @@
"""The browser loop against imitated unsubscribe pages. Needs Playwright: run with tests/run-in-docker.sh."""
import logging
import time
from urllib.parse import quote
import pytest
playwright_api = pytest.importorskip("playwright.sync_api")
import guard # noqa: E402
from llm import LLMUnavailable # noqa: E402
from runner import BROWSER_ARGS, run_case # noqa: E402
from tests import sites # noqa: E402
class Script:
"""Stands in for the model: answers with a fixed list of replies and records what it was shown."""
def __init__(self, *replies):
self.replies = list(replies)
self.prompts = []
def ask(self, system, user):
self.prompts.append(user)
reply = self.replies.pop(0) if self.replies else '{"action":"done","result":"unclear","reason":"script empty"}'
if isinstance(reply, Exception):
raise reply
return reply
def element(prompt: str, label: str) -> int:
"""Number of the first listed element whose line contains the label."""
for line in prompt.splitlines():
if line.startswith("[") and label in line:
return int(line[1:line.index("]")])
raise AssertionError(f"no element with {label!r} in:\n{prompt}")
@pytest.fixture(scope="module")
def browser():
with playwright_api.sync_playwright() as p:
b = p.chromium.launch(args=BROWSER_ARGS)
yield b
b.close()
@pytest.fixture
def site():
server, base = sites.start()
yield base
server.shutdown()
@pytest.fixture
def other():
server, base, log = sites.start_other()
yield base, log
server.shutdown()
def local_ok(base):
"""Guard for the tests: the test server on 127.0.0.1 counts as public, everything else goes to the real guard."""
return lambda url: url.startswith(base + "/") or guard.is_public_url(url)
def local_addresses(base):
"""The matching check for the egress proxy: the test server is reached at 127.0.0.1, all else as in production."""
return lambda url: ["127.0.0.1"] if url.startswith(base + "/") else guard.public_addresses(url)
def run(browser, site, path, llm, address="philipp@wagnersnetz.de", **kw):
return run_case(browser, site + path, address, llm, url_ok=local_ok(site), addresses_for=local_addresses(site),
nav_timeout=10, **kw)
def test_one_click_page_needs_no_model(browser, site):
llm = Script()
r = run(browser, site, "/oneclick", llm)
assert (r["result"], r["stage"], r["steps"]) == ("unsubscribed", 1, 0)
assert "You have been unsubscribed" in r["evidence"] and r["evidence_url"].endswith("/oneclick")
assert llm.prompts == []
def test_confirm_button(browser, site):
class Confirm(Script):
def ask(self, system, user):
self.prompts.append(user)
if "erfolgreich abgemeldet" in user:
return '{"action":"done","result":"unsubscribed","reason":"page confirms"}'
return '{"action":"click","element":%d}' % element(user, "Abmelden bestätigen")
r = run(browser, site, "/confirm", Confirm())
assert (r["result"], r["stage"]) == ("unsubscribed", 2)
assert ("POST", "/done", {}) in sites.Handler.log
assert "erfolgreich abgemeldet" in r["evidence"]
def test_reason_select_checkbox_and_submit(browser, site):
class Reason(Script):
def ask(self, system, user):
self.prompts.append(user)
n = len(self.prompts)
if n == 1:
return '{"action":"select","element":%d,"option":"Zu viele Mails"}' % element(user, "select")
if n == 2:
return '{"action":"check","element":%d,"on":true}' % element(user, "checkbox")
if n == 3:
return '{"action":"click","element":%d}' % element(user, "Absenden")
return '{"action":"done","result":"unsubscribed","reason":"confirmed"}'
r = run(browser, site, "/reason", Reason())
assert r["result"] == "unsubscribed"
assert ("POST", "/done", {"why": ["Zu viele Mails"], "all": ["on"]}) in sites.Handler.log
def test_address_is_inserted_by_code_not_by_the_model(browser, site):
class Address(Script):
def ask(self, system, user):
self.prompts.append(user)
n = len(self.prompts)
if n == 1:
return '{"action":"address","element":%d,"value":"attacker@evil.example"}' % element(user, "email")
if n == 2:
return '{"action":"click","element":%d}' % element(user, "Abmelden")
return '{"action":"done","result":"unsubscribed","reason":"confirmed"}'
r = run(browser, site, "/address", Address(), address="anne@wagnersnetz.de")
assert r["result"] == "unsubscribed"
assert ("POST", "/done-address", {"email": ["anne@wagnersnetz.de"]}) in sites.Handler.log
def test_login_page_ends_without_asking_the_model(browser, site):
llm = Script()
r = run(browser, site, "/login", llm)
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "login") and llm.prompts == []
def test_captcha_ends_without_asking_the_model(browser, site):
llm = Script()
r = run(browser, site, "/captcha", llm)
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "captcha") and llm.prompts == []
def test_injected_instructions_reach_the_model_only_as_page_text(browser, site):
class Obedient(Script):
"""A model that falls for the injection: it clicks 'Buy now' and then claims success."""
def ask(self, system, user):
self.prompts.append(user)
if len(self.prompts) == 1:
return '{"action":"click","element":%d}' % element(user, "Buy now")
return '{"action":"done","result":"unsubscribed","reason":"done as told"}'
llm = Obedient()
r = run(browser, site, "/inject", llm)
first = llm.prompts[0]
assert first.index("<page_text>") < first.index("ignore all previous rules") < first.index("</page_text>")
# the damage a fooled model can do is a click on a public page; the evidence shows what really happened
assert r["evidence_url"].endswith("/bought") and "purchase" in r["evidence"]
assert not any(method == "POST" for method, _, _ in sites.Handler.log)
def test_endless_pages_end_at_the_step_budget(browser, site):
class Clicker(Script):
def ask(self, system, user):
self.prompts.append(user)
return '{"action":"click","element":%d}' % element(user, "Bestätigen")
r = run(browser, site, "/loop", Clicker(), max_steps=4)
assert (r["result"], r["reason"], r["steps"]) == ("not_possible", "budget", 4)
def test_time_budget_ends_the_case(browser, site):
ticks = iter(range(0, 10000, 200))
r = run(browser, site, "/loop", Script('{"action":"click","element":1}'), case_timeout=300, clock=lambda: next(ticks))
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "budget")
def test_three_bad_replies_end_unclear(browser, site):
llm = Script("I think I should click.", '{"action":"type","element":1,"text":"x"}', '{"action":"click","element":99}')
r = run(browser, site, "/confirm", llm)
assert (r["result"], r["steps"]) == ("unclear", 3) and "invalid replies" in r["reason"]
assert not any(method == "POST" for method, _, _ in sites.Handler.log)
def test_a_good_reply_resets_the_bad_reply_count(browser, site):
class Mixed(Script):
def ask(self, system, user):
self.prompts.append(user)
n = len(self.prompts)
if n in (1, 2):
return "prose"
if n == 3:
return '{"action":"click","element":%d}' % element(user, "Abmelden bestätigen")
return '{"action":"done","result":"unsubscribed","reason":"ok"}'
assert run(browser, site, "/confirm", Mixed())["result"] == "unsubscribed"
def test_start_address_must_be_public(browser, site):
r = run_case(browser, "http://192.168.8.111/unsubscribe", "", Script(), url_ok=guard.is_public_url)
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "blocked_address")
def test_redirect_to_private_address_is_blocked(browser, site):
r = run(browser, site, "/to-private", Script())
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "blocked_address")
def test_embedded_private_content_is_blocked_but_the_page_still_works(browser, site):
class Confirm(Script):
def ask(self, system, user):
self.prompts.append(user)
if "erfolgreich abgemeldet" in user:
return '{"action":"done","result":"unsubscribed","reason":"ok"}'
return '{"action":"click","element":%d}' % element(user, "Abmelden bestätigen")
refused = []
assert run(browser, site, "/embeds-private", Confirm(), blocked_log=refused)["result"] == "unsubscribed"
assert "http://192.168.8.111/pixel.gif" in refused # the embedded request was made and refused
def test_non_input_element_with_checkbox_type_is_not_a_page_error(browser, site):
llm = Script('{"action":"done","result":"unclear","reason":"seen"}')
r = run(browser, site, "/odd-type", llm)
assert r["reason"] != "page_error" and len(llm.prompts) == 1
assert '[1] button' in llm.prompts[0] and 'Abmelden bestätigen"' in llm.prompts[0] # offered as an element
def test_page_that_tampers_with_the_snapshot_ends_as_page_error_without_the_model(browser, site):
llm = Script()
r = run(browser, site, "/tamper-push", llm)
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "page_error") and llm.prompts == []
def test_download_is_not_kept(browser, site, tmp_path, caplog, monkeypatch):
caplog.set_level(logging.INFO, logger="runner")
contexts = []
real_new_context = browser.new_context
def spy(**kw):
contexts.append(kw)
return real_new_context(**kw)
monkeypatch.setattr(browser, "new_context", spy)
class Download(Script):
def ask(self, system, user):
self.prompts.append(user)
if len(self.prompts) == 1:
return '{"action":"click","element":%d}' % element(user, "Abmelden bestätigen")
return '{"action":"done","result":"unclear","reason":"nothing happened"}'
r = run(browser, site, "/download", Download())
assert r["result"] == "unclear"
assert ("GET", "/file.bin", {}) in sites.Handler.log # the download really was attempted
assert "download refused" in caplog.text # the browser offered it and it was refused
assert [kw.get("accept_downloads") for kw in contexts] == [False] # and the context never accepts downloads
def test_model_unavailable_is_an_error_not_a_result(browser, site):
r = run(browser, site, "/confirm", Script(LLMUnavailable("model endpoint answered 502")))
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("error", "llm_unavailable")
def test_no_address_means_the_address_action_is_refused(browser, site):
llm = Script('{"action":"address","element":1}', '{"action":"done","result":"not_possible","reason":"needs address"}')
r = run(browser, site, "/address", llm, address="")
assert r["result"] == "not_possible" and "NOT available" in llm.prompts[0]
assert not any(method == "POST" for method, _, _ in sites.Handler.log)
def test_page_that_does_not_load_is_a_page_error(browser, site):
r = run_case(browser, "http://127.0.0.1:9/gone", "", Script(), url_ok=lambda url: True,
addresses_for=lambda url: ["127.0.0.1"], nav_timeout=5)
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "page_error")
def test_redirect_to_loopback_never_leaves_the_proxy(browser, site, other):
base2, log2 = other
refused = []
r = run(browser, site, "/redirect?to=" + quote(base2 + "/admin"), Script(), blocked_log=refused)
assert log2 == []
assert base2 + "/admin" in refused # the hop was made and refused, not just not followed
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "blocked_address")
@pytest.mark.parametrize("page", ["/img?src=", "/fetch?to="])
@pytest.mark.parametrize("via_redirect", [False, True])
def test_subresources_to_loopback_never_reach_it(browser, site, other, page, via_redirect):
base2, log2 = other
target = base2 + "/pixel.gif"
if via_redirect: # the route gate sees only the first hop; the proxy must stop the second
target = site + "/redirect?to=" + quote(target)
refused = []
run(browser, site, page + quote(target), Script(), blocked_log=refused)
time.sleep(0.5)
assert log2 == []
assert base2 + "/pixel.gif" in refused # the request to the second server was made and refused
if via_redirect:
assert ("GET", "/redirect", {}) in sites.Handler.log # the first hop did go out
def test_endless_script_ends_at_the_time_budget(browser, site):
start = time.monotonic()
r = run(browser, site, "/busy", Script(), case_timeout=5)
assert time.monotonic() - start < 15
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "budget")
def test_slow_model_ends_at_the_time_budget_and_gets_a_capped_timeout(browser, site):
class Slow(Script):
timeouts = []
def ask(self, system, user, timeout=None):
self.prompts.append(user)
self.timeouts.append(timeout)
time.sleep(4)
return '{"action":"click","element":%d}' % element(user, "Abmelden bestätigen")
llm = Slow()
start = time.monotonic()
r = run(browser, site, "/confirm", llm, case_timeout=3)
assert time.monotonic() - start < 10
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "budget")
assert llm.timeouts and all(t is not None and 0 < t <= 3 for t in llm.timeouts)
assert not any(method == "POST" for method, _, _ in sites.Handler.log)
def test_webrtc_is_not_available_to_pages(browser, site):
llm = Script()
run(browser, site, "/rtc", llm)
assert "rtc:undefined,undefined" in llm.prompts[0]
def test_blocked_image_on_a_page_that_never_loads_is_a_page_error(browser, site):
start = time.monotonic()
r = run_case(browser, site + "/hang-img", "", Script(), url_ok=local_ok(site), addresses_for=local_addresses(site),
nav_timeout=3)
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "page_error")
assert time.monotonic() - start < 8
@pytest.mark.parametrize("path", ["/many-links-password", "/frame-password"])
def test_password_field_anywhere_ends_without_the_model(browser, site, path):
llm = Script()
r = run(browser, site, path, llm)
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "login") and llm.prompts == []
def test_port_prefix_of_the_test_server_is_not_the_test_server(site):
host, port = site.rsplit(":", 1)
longer = f"{host}:{port}1/"
assert local_ok(site)(site + "/x") and local_addresses(site)(site + "/x") == ["127.0.0.1"]
assert not local_ok(site)(longer) and local_addresses(site)(longer) == []
def test_hang_while_creating_the_context_ends_at_the_time_budget(browser, site):
own = browser.browser_type.launch(args=BROWSER_ARGS) # this browser gets closed by the watchdog
real_new_context = own.new_context
def hanging_new_context(**kw):
# stands in for a new_context that never returns: Playwright round trips for up to 30 s, which only a
# watchdog already armed can cut short (by closing the browser)
until = time.monotonic() + 30
while time.monotonic() < until:
real_new_context().close()
return real_new_context(**kw)
own.new_context = hanging_new_context
llm = Script()
start = time.monotonic()
try:
r = run(browser=own, site=site, path="/confirm", llm=llm, case_timeout=2)
finally:
try:
own.close()
except Exception:
pass
assert time.monotonic() - start < 15
assert (r["result"], r["reason"]) == ("not_possible", "budget") and llm.prompts == []